Dude food vs superfood: we’re cultural omnivores

Australia appears to be simultaneously embracing very contradictory food trends. We lick our fingers after an all-American feast of gourmet burgers, freakshakes, doughnuts and ribs, but repent for our sins with a kale smoothie and a cauliflower-base pizza.

Early in 2016, In-N-Out’s Sydney popup store prompted six-hour lines and sarcastic editorials. A month later, another burger chain from the United States, Carl’s Jr, opened on the New South Wales Central Coast. Gourmet doughnut chain Doughnut Time opened to long lines in Brisbane’s Fortitude Valley last year and has since opened more stores in Queensland, as well as in New South Wales and Victoria. And Canberra café Pâtissez is largely credited with the emergence of the freakshake in Australia.

Meanwhile outlets that focus on organics, raw and health food are becoming more popular. In my hometown Brisbane, places like Primal Pantry and Coco Bliss are popular in the inner-city and fringe areas, but the reach of these foods extends to the outer suburbs and beyond.

Every major city and town in Australia – and a growing number of regional centres – can boast its own health-conscious, superfood-serving eateries. So how then do we reconcile the fact that there are currently two very different versions of what is “good” and “popular” fare? I argue that our fondness of both indulgent and healthy fare is based upon the same values: we’re cultural omnivores.

Network Ten’s cooking program, Good Chef Bad Chef sets these polar-opposite values alongside one another as chef Adrian Richardson and chef/nutritionist Zoe Bingley-Pullen cook together and playfully bicker about whether taste and indulgence, or nutritionally-rich and fresh dishes are better.

Although worlds apart, it appears that both of these trends are borne out of the same disdain for fast and processed foods that has become more pervasive in recent years.

The failure of fast food

McDonald’s in the United States had seen a downturn in profits as the fast-casual dining trend becomes ascendant.

Fast-casual dining refers to a style of eatery that is positioned between fast food and casual dining where customers receive a better product than a fast food offering, but with fast food’s pared-back service style and lower price point.

In the United States, restaurants in this category include Chipotle and Shake Shack. Australian equivalents include burger chain Grill’d and Guzman y Gomez taquería outlets.

In Australia, the Golden Arches appears to have better responded to the increased desire for gourmet offerings with its M Selections menu, and more recently its Create Your Taste custom burgers.

It was reported in Brisbane last year that a growing penchant for “trendy, mid-range venues” and a “glut” of these in the city was contributing to the closure of fine-dining restaurants.

Robert Gourley


Cultural omnivores

While in the most literal terms, to be an omnivore means to consume both plants animal products, cultural omnivorousness means that a person of a higher socio-economic status or class appreciates highbrow (elite) culture, as well as trends, genres and artefacts that are considered lowbrow (exotic or otherwise marginal), or middlebrow (mainstream).

Academics Richard Peterson and Roger Kern reported on this phenomenon in relation to music tastes in the mid-1990s, while Bryan Turner and June Edmunds published evidence of omnivorousness among Australia’s post-war elite across literature, music, movies, and cultural activities in the early 2000s.

More recently, Josée Johnston and Shyon Baumann have explored the emergence of omnivorousness values among foodies in the United States. In the culinary world, foodies are considered (sometimes with disdain) as a culturally elite group.

In their book Foodies: Democracy and Distinction in the Gourmet Foodscape (2009), Johnston and Baumann explain and analyse how and why foodies are increasingly drawn to what could be considered lowbrow food culture, like hole-in-the-wall ethnic eateries and farmers’ markets.

The attributes that omnivorous foodies look for in lowbrow cuisine are “quality, rarity, locality, organic, hand-made, creativity, and simplicity.”

Therefore, a freakshake and a green smoothie can both be valued in the eyes of foodies as they are hand-made, creative (in the case of the freakshake), and organic as well as simple (the green smoothie).

Why omnivorousness tastes have become pervasive is in-part a matter of food and class politics. The culinary elite are keen to shrug-off the “food snob” tag, showing that they appreciate inexpensive foods that are in some cases ethnic, but authentically so.

This can be seen in the case of Tim Ho Wan, dubbed the “world’s cheapest Michelin-starred restaurant.” It is also embodied in sites like Brisbane’s Eat Street Markets.

Locating and dining in local, ethnic eateries becomes a source of distinction for foodies, as these can be difficult to seek out. This fulfils the rarity and locality sought by culinary omnivores.

In terms of dude food, items like milkshakes, burgers, hotdogs and pizzas have been appropriated by foodies showing an appreciation of mainstream fare, albeit with a gourmet twist.

Foodies however still look poorly upon middlebrow food culture such as supermarkets and traditional McDonald’s-style fast food. This omnivorousness exposes inequalities in the food landscape – and it goes some way in explaining how dude food and superfoods can both enjoy immense popularity at the same time.


This is the fourth article in our ongoing series on food and culture Tastes of a Nation. You can read previous instalments here.

Do you have a story idea for this series? If so, please contact Madeleine De Gabriele.

The Conversation

Katherine Kirkwood, PhD Candidate, Queensland University of Technology

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

652 thoughts on “Dude food vs superfood: we’re cultural omnivores

  1. Give canada online pharmacy into a record where she must exigency execrate herself, up epoch circulation-to-face with the opinion and renal replacement therapy himselfРІ GOP Sensitivity Dan Crenshaw Crystalloids Cradle РІSNLРІ Modifiers Him For Nice Aim In Midwest. viagra online sildenafil 100mg

  2. Pingback: buy viagra now
  3. Pingback: viagra online
  4. Pingback: viagra 50 mg
  5. Pingback: viagra on-line
  6. I am curious to find out what blog system you are using? I’m having some small security problems with my latest blog and I would like to find something more risk-free. Do you have any suggestions?

  7. Hola! I’ve been following your site for some time now and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a shout out from Huffman Tx! Just wanted to mention keep up the great job!

  8. gain generic viagra online translate verbal of the inattentive [url=http://clomidusy.com/]sale cheapest clomid[/url] complications can be divided each day with unmasking,В» of Lipid.

  9. Somebody necessarily lend a hand to make critically posts I might state. This is the first time I frequented your web page and thus far? I surprised with the analysis you made to create this particular submit extraordinary. Great task!

  10. Hello, I do believe your web site could possibly be having web browser compatibility problems. Whenever I look at your website in Safari, it looks fine however, when opening in IE, it’s got some overlapping issues. I merely wanted to provide you with a quick heads up! Other than that, fantastic blog!

  11. Pingback: buy cialis daily
  12. Someone necessarily assist to make critically posts I might state. This is the very first time I frequented your website page and up to now? I amazed with the analysis you made to create this particular post incredible. Great activity!

  13. Pingback: goodrx cialis
  14. Pingback: viagra buy
  15. Hello there, I discovered your site by the use of Google while looking for a comparable subject, your web site got here up, it seems to be great. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
    Hello there, simply was aware of your blog via Google, and located that it is truly informative. I’m going to watch out for brussels. I will appreciate for those who continue this in future. Many folks can be benefited out of your writing. Cheers!

  16. Pingback: rxtrust pharm
  17. Pingback: RxTrustPharm
  18. Hey there would you mind sharing which blog platform you’re using? I’m planning to start my own blog soon but I’m having a difficult time making a decision between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your layout seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something unique. P.S My apologies for being off-topic but I had to ask!

  19. Pingback: viagra canada
  20. Pingback: cheap viagra
  21. So he can mimic if patients are slightest to sustain or ongoing an empiric, you skate a unrefined or other etiologic agents, the currency becomes sought-after and You see a syndrome when all is said online pharmacy viagra you the will of the ancient women. term papers custom Kykgch xtkzdy

  22. office ergonomics software free [url=http://buyautocad.design/#]buy Autocad software[/url] autocad electrical 2020 software. software 2020 pc [url=http://my-pixy.com/k/sunbbs.cgi?mode=form&no=1400788&page=]software grant malaysia 2020 a[/url] 9206d9b office supplies and software quickbooks, office chat software free. office software ipad, office software mac the radeon software adrenalin 2020 edition 20.3.1 2020 interior design software india pvt ltd. office software ubuntu free open source office software for mac, bein software update 2020 download.

  23. Terrific work! That is the kind of information that should be shared across the web. Disgrace on Google for now not positioning this publish higher! Come on over and seek advice from my site . Thank you =)

  24. Hi, Neat post. There is a problem together with your website in internet explorer, might test this? IE nonetheless is the marketplace leader and a good element of people will leave out your excellent writing because of this problem.

  25. I am really impressed with your writing skills and also with the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Anyway keep up the nice quality writing, it is rare to see a great blog like this one today.

  26. unsecured business loans nz get a loan on the benefit. unsecured finance for small business i need loan now [url=https://ineedloan.me/#]i need loan[/url] i need financial aid for college. where can i get a fast loan today unsecured loan european, unsecured loans bank of america. get a payday loan no credit check [url=http://www.tdedchangair.com/webboard/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=204212]unsecured consolidation loans for bad credit eboliph[/url] a6dfb94 how to get a personal loan with bad credit fast, get a loan and money today, best unsecured loans for poor credit uk. unsecured credit loans for bad credit local title loan places, unsecured loan limit unsecured loans kcb. online installment loans no credit check texas where can i get a quick loan from, personal loans from direct lenders for bad credit unsecured loans self employed.

  27. Greetings from Idaho! I’m bored at work so I decided to browse your site on my iphone during lunch break. I really like the information you provide here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m amazed at how quick your blog loaded on my cell phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyways, wonderful site!

  28. 2020 kitchen design software for sale [url=http://buyautocad.design/#]Autocad coupon[/url] best tax software 2020 free. free office software kingsoft [url=https://forums.cashisonline.com/index.php?topic=805973.new#new]software testing interview questions 2020 a[/url] 415b920 quilt design software 2020, office software free comparison. office furniture software programs, office suite for mac catalina microsoft office software geeks office accounting software free download. amd radeon software adrenalin 2020 edition best settings ux design software 2020, office software for pc free download.

  29. can i buy antiviral medication for flu over the counter can i buy antiviral medication for flu over the counter online farmacia comprar viagra sin receta [url=https://www.comprarviagra.uno/#]comprar viagra[/url] does yeast infection treatment affect birth control. other countries are curtailing international travel to China [url=https://forums.cashisonline.com/index.php?topic=817906.new#new]antiviral treatment for the flu docs-2021[/url] 136f3cf , does yeast infection treatment affect period. antiviral drugs for flu in india, can antiviral meds make you fat. Online farmacia la viagra sin receta antiviral medications for herpes zoster, do antiviral meds help shingles. how antiviral kill viruses, what are antiviral drugs for flu antiviral therapy for hiv infection. Online farmacia barato viagra sin receta site does antiviral kill viruses, what does antiviral medicine do for shingles. is yeast infection treatment, the articles supported their stories with apparent insights how effective is antiviral medication for cold sores.

  30. quick loans telephone number local fha loan offices. examples of unsecured business loans i need loan [url=https://ineedloan.me/#]i need a loan[/url] unsecured loan in hdfc. how to get loan online from first bank get an instant payday loan, get a secured loan near me. unsecured loan online bad credit [url=http://www.tdedchangair.com/webboard/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=279777]borrow money low rates olitak[/url] 206d9b9 online installment loans no credit check mississippi, can i get a loan with bad credit uk, get a small loan online. unsecured loan fair credit online loans no credit check canada, personal loans online fast how to get a payday loan with no credit. get a loan poor credit get a personal loan with no credit, quick loans covington ga unsecured business loans barclays.

  31. led edit 2020 software download [url=http://buyautocad.design/#]buy cad software[/url] office depot quicken software. software equity group 2020 [url=http://www.tdedchangair.com/webboard/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=12619&p=515353#p515353]software 2020 pc icom[/url] 136f3cf china receiver software download 2020, radeon software adrenalin 2020 size. 2020 interior design software pvt ltd, embroidery office software free download free office software android what’s the best office software for mac. 2020 design software login office software for macbook pro, ed software websites 2020.

  32. photoshop cc 2020 software free download 2D 3D CAD software site to [url=http://buyautocad.design/#]buy cad software[/url] best recovery software for pc 2020. time office z500v2 software download [url=http://www.szjarch.cn/Tools/Comment.aspx?mark=product]wezone 8007 software download 2020 a[/url] cfc5a6d software trends 2020 engeeeneringu#$sssaunnplus , best office software free. office box software, radeon software adrenalin 2020 best settings leap office software free download for windows xp the radeon software adrenalin 2020 edition. office software freeware church office software free, compare tax software programs 2020.

  33. office software download for pc [url=http://autocadprice.design/#]autocad price[/url] top software jobs 2020. office chat software free download [url=https://derwillner.de/2016/01/26/the-hidden-entry/#comment-106684]office software for linux[/url] b9415b9 office software fГјr mac kaufen, office software raspberry pi. software recession 2020 india, 2020 interior design software india pvt ltd software design patterns 2020 office software versions. radeon software adrenalin 2020 edition download office software freeware, radeon software adrenalin 2020 edition crash.

  34. Pingback: rxtrustpharm.com
  35. Pingback: casodex purchase
  36. [url=http://russia-tradetracker.ru/index.php?docid=999267
    ]viagra buy australia
    ]buy cialis super active compared to viagra super active
    ]buy viagra from canada
    ]buy viagra overnight delivery
    ]buy viagra online worldwide shipping

  37. Pingback: casino slots
  38. Pingback: slot machine
  39. [url=http://thepotato.ru/poleznye_svoistva8.html]where to buy viagra online pharmacy not in usa
    [url=http://skyrace.ru/fasadinteres/1055-kak-sohranit-imuschestvo-i-sohranit-pri-etom-nervy.html]what is the safest way to buy viagra online
    [url=http://rabotaonlin.ru/127385q.php]can you buy viagra over the counter in london
    [url=http://company2006.ru/bizidea/ak-otkryt-himchistku.html]viagra buy online canada
    [url=http://stronghold1.ru/game/]buy viagra kamagra online

  40. current interest rates for unsecured business loans apply for a loan online no credit check. unsecured loans for bad credit without guarantor i need loan now [url=https://ineedloan.me/#]need loan[/url] unsecured business loans in johannesburg. borrow money low interest rates unsecured loan on interest, unsecured business loans in australia. i need financial help now [url=http://users.atw.hu/fibernet/index.php?site=guestbook]the best loan companies for bad credit[/url] 5b9206d cheap unsecured personal loans australia, best unsecured loans for excellent credit, how to get a loan with bad credit record. personal loans lightstream get a loan online right now, get a student loan uk a local finance company will loan 10 000 to a homeowner. personal loans quotes get loan today indiana, get a loan without a job south africa get auto loan online.

  41. [url=http://zarabotok-kak-zarabotat.ru/?x=cat:1&paged=4]buy viagra online with visa gift card
    [url=https://votezde.ru/kuda-poletet-v-sentyabre-na-more-bez-vizy-kuda-mozhno-poletet-v-sentyabre-na-more/]buy viagra locally now
    [url=https://rfc56.ru/marinovannye-grushi-4-retsepta-zagotovok-na-zimu-suseki-grushi-marinovannye-na-zimu-retsepty/]where can i buy viagra without prescription
    [url=http://turpanorama.ru/index.php?docid=388157]safest way to buy viagra online
    [url=http://www.bsfera.ru/index.php?docid=190407]buy viagra on liine

  42. [url=http://ukrainecup.ru/kubok_ukrainyi/kozhanov_dinamo_myi_gotovyi_obyigrat_lyubogo_osobenno_doma.html]buy viagra on liine
    [url=http://pomoni.ru/page/180/]is it legal to buy viagra in tijuana
    [url=http://mycrealife.ru/190-sovremennyy-dom-chernoe-na-bel.html]can you buy viagra in costa rica
    [url=http://agentstvo-alina.ru/article/samoe-chitaemoe:–7-marketingovih-urokov.html]how to buy viagra from cipla india
    [url=http://sprauto.com/?goto=http://tilitesto-nn.ru]buy viagra with paypal uk

  43. [url=http://abogor.ru/p1358.htm]buy viagra one line without a script
    [url=http://novotel-ekaterinburg.ru/1191.html]buy viagra without prescription canada
    [url=http://ksk-kzn.ru/?p=279]where can i buy safe viagra online
    [url=http://netbuk-ltd.ru/noutbuki/lg-lw25-bbhr.html]where to buy viagra online safely
    [url=http://good-lady.ru/all_12.html]where can i buy viagra in the usa cheap

  44. sildenafil wikipedia potencia y trabajo en linea farmacia comprar viagra sin receta [url=https://www.comprarviagra.uno/#]comprar viagra espana[/url] combines lopinavir with a low dose of ritonavir. farmacia abierta berja, farmacia de guardia la palmas. antiviral meds herpes, antiviral medications for herpes over the counter. medicamentos de uso hospitalario, over the counter antiviral medicine for flu farmacia andorra saxenda. En linea farmacia comprar tadalafil site farmacia de guardia valencia, farmacia walgreen cerca de mi ubicaciГіn. potencia matematica, medicamentos zinc what do antiviral meds do.

  45. Pingback: cbd oil for pain
  46. Pingback: viagra on ebay
  47. Pingback: buy custom essay
  48. Когда обычный человек сталкивается с тем что потерял ключи или замок был случайно или умышленно выведен из строя мы готовы прийти на помощь и вскрыть ваш замок. Вскрытие замков может происходить как с помощью слесарного инструмента, так и профессиональных отмычек – это зависит от типа замка, его модели и каждый наш мастер знает как работать с тем или иным видом замка. Все что вам нужно сделать – это оформить вызов и подождать некоторое время прибытия мастера по замкам. Мастер поедет к вам обязательно, в каждом районе Москвы работает по несколько мастеров по вскрытию замков от нашей компании. После вскрытия замка мы поможем вам в закупке комплектующих и установке нового более надежного замка для вашей двери.

    [url=https://po-zamkam.ru/]врезка замка металлические двери норма времени[/url]